Belief in God is rational. Everything has a cause. So unless there is a first cause, then you would have an infinite regress. And then nothing could exist. Therefore there must be a first cause. Therefore God, the first cause, exists. QED.
29.10.26
I would like to attempt a possible answer to what I was answering in my previous blog on the question of Rav Shach on Tosphot. Tosphot asks how do we know that the value of money acquires a woman? Answer the fact that the value of money can acquire a Jewish slave. Question of Rav Shach. That only works in one direction to acquire but to redeem Jewish slave one has to give money to the gentile owner. So, the Gezera Shava is only half of one. Answer the verse itself is talking about redemption of a Jewish slave. That is the major point of the verse. so, we are not ignoring that fact but rather taking notice that redemption of Jewish slave is relevant to redeeming him from an obligation. That part of the verse is not relevant to marrying a woman. In that case getting out of a marriage is with a document of divorcee. The only part of the verse that relates to a woman is the ability of the value of money to cause acquisition. -----------------------------------------------I would like to attempt a possible answer to what I was answering in my previous blog on the question of רב שך on תוספות. The issue is this. תוספות asks how do we know that the value of money acquires a woman? Answer the fact that the value of money can acquire a Jewish slave. Question of רב שך. That only works in one direction to acquire but to redeem Jewish slave one has to give money to the gentile owner. So, theגזרה שווה is only half of גזרה שווה. Answer the verse itself is talking about redemption of a Jewish slave. .כסף ישיב לבעליו ויקרא כ''ה That is the major point of the verse. So, we are not ignoring that fact, but rather taking notice that redemption of Jewish slave is relevant to redeeming him from an obligation. That part of the verse is not relevant to marrying a woman. In that case, getting out of a marriage is with a document of divorce. The only part of the verse that relates to a woman is the ability of the value of money to cause acquisition. [Later I saw that Rav Shach answers this own question (laws of marriage, chapter 3, law 1) after a few closely argued pages that a redemption of a Jewish slave is] acquired [to himself] .and something that causes acquisition (buys something) by means of exchange has to be coin.---------------[Later I saw that רב שך answers this own question (laws of marriage, chapter 3, law 1) )after a few closely argued pages( that a redemption of a Jewish slave is acquisition [to himself], and something that causes acquisition (buys something) by means of exchange has to be coins.-not exchange.. [I would like to mention here that the basic people that deal with this subject are Rav Shach, Reb Shmuel Rozovski of Poniovitch [in the book, Zichron Shmuel] and the Divrei Echezkil of Slobodka.--Normally speaking I would have tried to go through the basic Rishonim and Achronim, and not say a word until I had gained some sort of clarity or insight into this subject. However, I have been busy with going to a hospital in Kfar Sabsa and getting chemicals poured into me, and besides that I might simply be getting old and worn out. However, if I can, I would like to share with people any insight that I might be blessed with.---] --------------I might mention here also that Rav Shach points out that the law of ''freeing a non jewish slave can be by money or the value of money, but not exchange'' means not exchange by kinyan sudar [acquisition by exchange of a handchercheif]--. but exchange ''this for that'' would work. However that would not work for a Jewish slave that is owned by a gentile because the act of freeing him has to by by coin--not the value of money because you need a act of causing the acquisition.-----I think Rav Shach means this: That the freeing of a Jewish slave from a gentile has to be by coin because it is not a case of something being bought and something being sold. Even though his body has been bought, the Gemara itself says that hiring a worker is like being a slave for a few hours during the time of being hired. The exchange of this for that would work to free a gentile slave but nota Jewish slave being there is no exchange-----I think רב שך means this: That the freeing of a עבד עברי from a gentile has to be by coin because it is not a case of something being bought and something being sold. Even though his body has been bought, the גמרא itself says that hiring a worker is like being a slave for a few hours during the time of being hired. The exchange of שווה בשווה would work to free a עבד כנעני but not a Jewish slave בגלל there is no exchange
