Translate

Powered By Blogger

18.2.15


 The Rambam (Maimonides) had a system. The idea of his system was that in the Torah there are no contradictions; and he expanded that to include the Talmud. So in his system there is no contradiction between Torah and Talmud. Furthermore he also had a modified Neo-Platonic and Aristotelian system {that he does not define exactly} and this system he hold is the underlying world view of Torah.

The idea that there is no contradiction in Torah was common in the Middle Ages.  It led Aquinas to create his system based on his idea that there is no contradiction between the Old Testament and the NT and later people called the "church fathers" and Boethius.

This is very different from today when people feel they individually interpret the Torah to mean what they feel it means to them. Or when groups interpret the Torah to mean what it means to their particular deluded leader.

There is no idea that the Torah is a self consistant whole that means something very specific and and nothing else. And that meaning can be discovered by human reason. For if it could not be discovered, then why was the Torah given at all in the first place? So in terms of understanding the Torah we have to call the Middle Ages the "Age of Reason." The period starting after the Middle Ages we should call "The Age of Darkness."

Even in Musar you can see this. Musar had three distinct periods: (1) The Middle Ages, (2)  then all Musar became Kabalistic, and then (3) the post Israel Salanter Musar which was getting back to \the Talmud kind of Musar.