Translate

Powered By Blogger

31.1.22

mysticism based on the Zohar

 The problem with mysticism based on the Zohar is the phrase עם כל דא "even though".[עם כל דא "  is used all the time in the Zohar.]  I mean to say that the Zohar was written during the Middle Ages after that phrase עם כל זה [translated in Aramaic  עם כל דא] was invented by the Ibn Tibon family. Before then one said "even though" by אף על פי or  אף על גב. [Rav Yakov Emden in fact noticed the problem. He concluded that some parts of the Zohar were based on mystic writings that had come before that time, but a lot of it was not from R Shimon ben Yochai.

So while I have a lot of respect for the great mystics like Rav Avraham Abulafia and Rav Isaac Luria,, I do not see the Zohar as having validity at all.