Translate

Powered By Blogger

17.11.26

kidushin page 2 and page 8.

I was at the hospital most of the daylight hours, and then I hailed a taxi to get to the Litvack kollel to join in with the afternoon learning. Then I discovered I did not have enough for the taxi, so he let me off and I took a bus. by the time I got back it was clear the learning at the kollel was over so I went to the sea. On the way back I was flooded with thoughts about the Avi Ezri on the Rambam laws of marriage chapter 3 law 1. but I can’t put them n order since the more I tried to put them in order the more they flooded my head. so, I will try to write down in short what some of the issues are. first of all. The question of Rav Shach does not depend on the idea that the value of money acquires by barter. It simply depends on the idea that the Jewish slave is not redeemed by anything but money, coins. From where this comes from, I do not know, but I have hope to find out. At the kolllel there is a rav who knows Choshen Mishpat very well so maybe I’ll ask him. [2] The idea of Tosphot comes from the Gemara on page 8. The Gemara brings a Braita that says we know the value of money is like money from a verse about a Jewish slave. “Silver he will return to the owner, and be let go free.” The braita adds, “that includes the value of money.” Tosphot only adds to this that from here we apply the value of money to marriage. --that it acquires a woman. [3] Is it possible that the Rambam learns from that Braita a Jewish slave is bought by money of the value of money but to be redeemed he needs silver? after all the braita says we learn from the verse that the value of money is like money but that can refer only to buying the slave because to redeem the slave it says openly that he needs silver, i.e., coin. [4] But that Braita contradicts the whole idea of Reb Chaim of brisk that in the approach of the Rambam the value of money acquires by barter for it says openly the value of money acquires like money and the Gemara explains the Braita that says he can not be acquired by vessels or grain that the braita refers to exchange.{5} maybe tosphot does not mean it is a gezra shava from the value of money acquires a Jewish slave to it acquires a woman.? Maybe it is a “What do we find?-----------------------------------------------------[I was at the hospital most of the daylight hours, and then I hailed a taxi to get to the Litvack kollel to join in with the afternoon learning. Then I discovered I did not have enough for the taxi, so he let me off and I took a bus. by the time I got back it was clear the learning at the כולל was over, so I went to the sea. on the way back I was flooded with thoughts about the אבי עזרי on the רמב''ם laws of אישות chapter 3 law 1. but I can’t put them n order since the more I tried to put them in order the more they flooded my head. so, I will try to write down in short what some of the issues are. first of all. the question of רב שך does not depend on the idea that the value of money acquires by חליפין. It simply depends on the idea that the Jewish slave is not redeemed by anything but money, coins. From where this comes from, I do not know, but I have hope to find out. At the כולל there is a רב who knows חושן משפט very well so maybe I’ll ask him. [2] The idea of תוספות comes from the גמרא on page ח'. The גמרא brings a ברייתא that says we know the value of money is like money from a verse about a Jewish slave. כסף ישיב לבעליו, and be let go free. The ברייתא adds, “that includes the value of money.” תוספות only adds to this that from here we apply the value of money to marriage. --that it acquires a woman. [3] Is it possible that the רמב''ם learns from that ברייתא a Jewish slave is bought by money of the value of money, but to be redeemed he needs silver? after all the ברייתא says we learn from the verse that the value of money is like money but that can refer only to buying the slave because to redeem the slave it says openly that he needs silver, i.e., coin. [4] But that ברייתא contradicts the whole idea of רב חיים of Brisk that in the approach of theרמב''ם the value of money acquires by barter for it says openly the value of money acquires like money and the גמרא explains the ברייתא that says he can not be acquired by vessels or grain that the ברייתא refers to exchange.{5} Maybe תוספות does not mean it is a גזרה from the value of money acquires a Jewish slave to it acquires a woman.? Maybe it is a “What do we find? [6] רב יוסף brings that ברייתא for a proof of his law that if one marries with leftovers of silk, the monetary value needs to be evaluated. The law is later rejected, and the גמרא itself says that ברייתא might mean that barter cannot acquire a Jewish slave, but the basic law the value of money is like money stays unaffected. So, the question is valid. We know the value of money is like mone,ת but not barter. So, then how would we learn the value money acquires a woman if the value of money itself is half a teaching? For it acquires a Jewish slave, but does not redeem him.]