The way I recommend doing Gemara is to do every day a 1/2 daf [i.e., one whole side of a page] with Rashi, Tosfot, Maharsha and Maharam of Lublin. The way to do the daf itself would be with two fingers--one on the words of the Gemara and the other finger on the Rashi--and thus go through that entire half page with the Gemara and Rashi together and then the Tosphot. If possible to add the Pnei Yehoshua and Aruch Laner.